Have you ever walked down the street and seen a roof with two distinct slopes? These kinds of roofs are known as mansard roofs and they provide a lot of additional attic space without having to get too involved with adding additional floors.
But what makes them unique? What exactly is a “mansard roof”?
A mansard roof is a type of roofing design characterized by its double-sloped design, dormer windows, and additional living or storage space. It is named after the French architect François Mansart, who popularized the design in the 17th century. The mansard roof is a distinctive and elegant roofing design that has been used extensively in French and American architecture.
On one steep side, there were windows slit into the roof, letting in beautiful light.
In this article I’ll explain what exactly a mansard roof is, why homeowners prefer it, and their advantages and disadvantages.
By the way – before we get too far along here, if you want to connect with other homeowners and builders and get more great ideas for your home to make your space the best join my free private Facebook group, Remodel Reality here.
The Mansard Roof: An Overview
A mansard roof, also known as a French roof, is a type of roof characterized by its double-sloped design. The roof has two slopes on all four sides, with the lower slope having a steeper angle than the upper slope. The steep lower slope can be nearly vertical or may have a slight curvature, while the upper slope is almost horizontal. The roof design allows for an increased living or storage space beneath the roof, often in the form of an additional floor or attic. The name “mansard” comes from the French architect François Mansart, who popularized the design in the 17th century.
Historical background
The mansard roof design originated in France during the 16th century, but it was not until the 17th century that the style became popular. François Mansart, a renowned French architect [1], is credited with popularizing the design during the reign of Louis XIII. The design became popular among the French aristocracy and quickly spread throughout Europe. Mansard roofs were commonly used in the construction of grand townhouses and chateaus, as well as public buildings such as churches and government buildings.
The design fell out of favor during the 18th and early 19th centuries, but it experienced a resurgence in popularity during the Second French Empire in the mid-19th century. Mansard roofs were used extensively in the construction of Parisian buildings during this period, particularly in the construction of the grand boulevards.
Purpose and benefits of a mansard roof
Did you know that one of the primary functions of a mansard roof is to provide additional living or storage space beneath the roof?
The double-sloped design of the mansard roof creates more headroom in the upper floor, making it a more comfortable living space. This additional space can be used for various purposes like creating extra bedrooms, offices, or even recreational areas.
This type of roofing system serves a multifaceted purpose that can benefit homeowners in many ways. Firstly, it offers additional living or storage space in the upper portion of the roof, making it a practical choice for those who need more space but don’t want to build an extension or add another floor to their home.
In addition to their practical uses, mansard roofs are also valued for their aesthetic qualities. Mansard roofs for residential homes were really popular in the 70s and 80s in the U.S. I live in an older neighborhood in Tallahassee and there are numerous houses in our area that have mansard roofs.
The unique design of this roofing system really delivers a distinctive look to any house and makes it stand out from others in the surrounding area. When you add in dormer windows to the double-sloped design it really adds character and a distinguished look.
It’s important to note that working on a mansard roof requires skilled roofers and engineers with experience working with this type of roofing system.
Mansard Roof Characteristics
The characteristics of a mansard roof are what make it unique and popular in architecture. From its double-sloped design (especially when combined with the use of dormer windows), the features of a mansard roof provide both aesthetic appeal and functional benefits.
Upper slope angle
The upper slope of a mansard roof is a lot closer to being flat than a traditional roof, with a slight slope of between 15 and 30 degrees. This angle provides a more gradual transition between the roof and the walls of the building, which gives the roof its distinctive look. The angle of the upper slope also plays a role in the design of the roof, as it affects the amount of light that enters the space beneath the roof.
Design variations
Mansard roofs come in a variety of designs, including full and half mansard roofs. A full mansard roof has a steep lower slope that covers virtually the entire height of the building, while the more traditional mansard roof has a lower slope that only covers the top portion of the height of the building.
In addition, a flat mansard roof has flat planes, a concave mansard roof has planes that are curved inward, and a convex mansard roof has planes that are curved outward that can really create a unique look for the structure.
Dormer windows
Dormer windows are a common feature of mansard roofs providing additional light and ventilation to the space beneath the roof. These are windows that are built into the roof structure, and they can be either functional or decorative. Functional dormer windows are designed to open and close, while decorative dormer windows are designed to add visual interest to the roof.
Materials used for mansard roofing
Mansard roofs can be constructed using a variety of materials, including slate, asphalt, wood shingles, and metal.
The type of material used for the roof will depend on the design of the building and the budget for the project. Slate and metal are popular choices for mansard roofs due to their durability and longevity, while asphalt and wood shingles are more affordable options that offer a similar aesthetic appeal that you see on a lot of those 70s and 80s houses.
The type of roofing material used will also affect the maintenance requirements for the roof, as different materials require different levels of maintenance to keep them in good condition.
Mansard vs. Other Roof Types
There are several different types of roofing designs, each with their own unique characteristics and benefits. In this section, we will compare and contrast the mansard roof with other types of roofing designs.
Gable roofs
A gable roof is one of the most common types of roofing designs. It is characterized by its triangular shape and steeply sloped sides. Unlike a mansard roof, a gable roof only has two sloping sides, which meet at a ridge or peak. Gable roofs are popular due to their simplicity and ease of construction. However, they do not offer as much living or storage space as a mansard roof.
Hip roofs
A hip roof is similar to a gable roof in that it has sloping sides, but the sides meet at a ridge that is not straight. Instead, the ridge is angled, which creates a more pyramid-like shape. Hip roofs are popular for their durability and stability, but they also offer less living or storage space than a mansard roof.
Gambrel roofs
A gambrel roof is a type of roof that has two sloping sides on each of its two sides, creating a barn-like appearance. Like the mansard roof, a gambrel roof offers additional living or storage space in the upper portion of the roof. However, gambrel roofs have a different slope angle and design than mansard roofs. Gambrel roofs are popular for their unique and rustic appearance.
Flat roofs
Flat roofs are a popular roofing design for commercial and industrial buildings, as well as modern homes. As the name suggests, a flat roof is a level surface that provides no pitch or slope. Flat roofs are popular for their modern and minimalistic appearance, as well as their low maintenance requirements. However, flat roofs are not as durable as mansard roofs and are prone to water damage if not properly maintained.
Overall, while each roofing design has its own unique characteristics and benefits, the mansard roof stands out for its double-sloped design and increased living or storage space.
| Roof Type | Slope Design | Additional Space | Aesthetics | Durability | Maintenance | Installation Cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mansard | Double-slope | Yes | Unique | High | Difficult | High |
| Gable | Single-slope | No | Simple | Moderate | Easy | Low |
| Hip | Angled | No | Stable | High | Moderate | Moderate |
| Gambrel | Barn-like | Yes | Rustic | High | Moderate | High |
| Flat | Level | No | Modern | Low | Easy | Low |
Mansard Roofing and Building Architecture
The mansard roof is a popular roofing design that has been used by architects and builders for centuries. In this section, we will explore the use of mansard roofs in building architecture, from the famous architects known for using them to their use in different types of buildings.
Famous architects known for using mansard roofs
Since François Mansart popularized this style of roof in the 17th century, numerous famous architects have followed suit and have used mansard roofs in their building designs. One famous architect who used mansard roofs is Richard Morris Hunt, an American architect who designed the Biltmore Estate in North Carolina.
Mansard roofs in French architecture
Mansard roofs are a common feature in French architecture. They were first popularized in France in the 17th century and have been used extensively in the construction of grand townhouses, chateaus, and public buildings like churches and government buildings. Mansard roofs are particularly prominent in Parisian architecture, where they are used extensively in the construction of the grand boulevards. Mansard roofs in French architecture are often characterized by their unique design variations and the use of ornate dormer windows.
Mansard roofs in American architecture
Mansard roofs have also been used extensively in American architecture. They became popular in the mid-19th century during the Second French Empire and were used extensively in the construction of public buildings, commercial buildings, and grand homes. Mansard roofs in American architecture are usually characterized by their simpler design variations and the use of simpler dormer windows. Notable examples of mansard roofs in American architecture include the 1870 Heck-Andrews House in Raleigh, North Carolina.
Mansard roofs in commercial and public buildings
Mansard roofs are a popular choice for commercial and public buildings – we’ve mentioned several here. They offer additional living or storage space, which can be used for a variety of purposes. Mansard roofs have been commonly used in the construction of hotels, apartment buildings, and office buildings. They are also commonly used in the construction of public buildings like museums and government buildings. The unique design of the mansard roof can provide a distinctive look to a building, making it stand out from other buildings in the area.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Mansard Roofs
While the mansard roof is a popular roofing design, it also comes with its own set of advantages and disadvantages. In this section, we will explore the advantages and disadvantages of mansard roofs in more detail.
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| Additional living space | High installation and repair costs |
| Better insulation | Difficult maintenance |
| Enhanced aesthetics | Limited durability |
Advantage: Additional living or home office space
One of the main advantages of a mansard roof is the additional living or storage space it provides. The double-sloped design of the mansard roof allows for more space in the upper portion of the roof, which can be used for a variety of purposes. This additional space can be particularly beneficial for homeowners who need extra living space but do not have the space or resources to add an extension or additional floor.
Advantage: Better insulation
Mansard roofs are also known for their superior insulation properties. The double-sloped design of the roof provides better insulation than other types of roofing designs, which can lead to lower heating and cooling costs. The additional insulation provided by a mansard roof can be particularly beneficial in colder climates, where energy costs can be high.
Advantage: Enhanced aesthetics
Another advantage of a mansard roof is its unique and distinctive design. Mansard roofs provide a certain elegance and charm to a building that other roofing designs may not offer. The use of dormer windows and the double-sloped design can add character and style to a building, making it stand out in the surrounding area.
Disadvantage: High installation and repair costs
One of the main disadvantages of a mansard roof is its high installation and repair costs. The complex design of the mansard roof requires skilled professionals to install and repair it properly, which can result in higher costs. Additionally, the materials used for mansard roofs, such as slate or copper, can also be expensive.
Disadvantage: Difficult maintenance
Maintaining a mansard roof can also be challenging. The design of the roof can make it difficult to access and maintain, particularly in the upper portions of the roof. Additionally, the use of dormer windows can also increase the complexity of maintaining a mansard roof.
Disadvantage: Limited durability
While mansard roofs offer many benefits, they may not be as durable as other types of roofing designs. The design of the roof can make it more prone to leaks and water damage, which can lead to costly repairs. Plus, if you live in an area where it snows in the winter, there is a tendendy for snow to accumulate. Additionally, the additional living or storage space provided by the mansard roof may lead to heavier loads on the roof, which can also contribute to its limited durability.
Next Steps
Want to join others who are creating the most amazing home redesigns & renovations and get more tips, tricks and hacks on how to make your home the best it can be?
Join my brand new free private Facebook group, Remodel Reality to connect with other people like you to make your space the best!
References
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francois_Mansart
Great blog here!