Digging A Basement Under An Existing House: Good Idea or Bust?


Spread The Word

In desperate need of more space in your home and considering digging a basement under your existing house?

Can that even be done – is it even a good idea?

Yes, you can dig a basement underneath an existing house, but it requires careful planning, structural assessments, compliance with local building codes, and collaboration with experienced professionals like structural engineers and general contractors. The project’s feasibility depends on factors like the existing structure, soil type, property size, and budget.

Digging a basement under an existing house is a major undertaking, but it can also be a great way to add living space to your home. Whether you want an extra bedroom, a home theater, or a game room, a basement can provide the perfect space.

However, before you start digging, there are a few things you need to consider.

In this article, we’ll explore the key considerations for digging a basement under an existing house, including the planning and preparation process, excavation methods, and potential challenges and costs and what alternatives you have if it just can’t be done.

By the way – before we get too far along here, if you want to connect with other homeowners, DIYers, and builders and get more great ideas for your home to make your space the best join my free private Facebook group, Remodel Reality here.

Can You Dig A Basement Underneath An Existing House?

Have you ever dreamed of expanding your living space by adding a basement to your existing home? You’re not alone! A basement can be a game-changer, offering additional storage, living space, or even a cozy getaway. However, digging a basement under an existing house comes with its own set of challenges and considerations. In this article, we’ll explore the ins and outs of transforming your home by adding a basement.

A well-designed basement can add significant value to your property and provide a whole new level of comfort and functionality. Whether you’re looking for extra basement space for a home office, gym, or entertainment room, a basement addition can be the perfect solution for your needs.

Before you start dreaming of your ideal basement, it’s essential to evaluate the feasibility of the project.

Pros & Cons of Adding A Basement To An Existing House

Adding a basement to your existing house comes with its fair share of pros and cons. On the one hand, you can enjoy increased living and storage space, a potential increase in property value, and the flexibility to design the space as you please. Additionally, creating functional spaces like a home office, gym, or guest room can greatly enhance your day-to-day life. In the right circumstances, a well-designed basement can also lead to improved energy efficiency and even income generation if you decide to create a rental unit.

On the other hand, the costs and complexities of basement construction can be significant. From dealing with local building codes and permits to addressing high water tables or poor soil conditions, there’s a lot to navigate. The disruption caused by construction and the potential challenges of working with existing structures, particularly in older or historical homes, can add to the overall difficulty of the project.

Pros Cons
Increased living and storage space High costs associated with excavation and construction
Potential increase in property value Possible disruption to daily life during construction
Additional room for a home office, gym, or guest room Challenges in working with existing structures
Customizable design to suit personal preferences Potential issues with local building codes and permits
Better utilization of available land Dealing with high water tables or poor soil conditions
Enhanced energy efficiency and temperature regulation Risk of flooding and the need for proper waterproofing
Potential income generation with a rental unit Longer construction timelines compared to other projects
Improved resale appeal to potential buyers Limitations due to older homes or historical properties

Evaluating the feasibility of adding a basement under an existing house

So now that we’ve covered the answer of the basic question whether or not you can add a basement to an existing house, let’s dive into the feasibility aspect. We need to discuss how to assess your existing structure, navigate local building codes, and consider the costs and potential impact on your property value to see if it’s even worth going through all the trouble.

Assessing the existing structure: Foundation type and condition

To get started, unless you’re a structural engineer it’s highly recommended that you get with one or with a general contractor who specializes in this kind of work. They’ll be able to assess your foundation and determine if it’s strong enough to support the additional weight and excavation process that comes with adding a basement. This is most definitely not an area where you want to be guessing, or estimating. You need precise, clear information.

Type of soil

Soil type is another vital factor to consider, because it can significantly impact the stability and drainage of your future basement. Some soil types, like clay or expansive soils, may require extra precautions during construction to ensure the structural integrity of your new basement.

Size of the house and property

The size of your house and property can also influence the feasibility of adding a basement. You’ll need to evaluate whether there’s enough space to accommodate the excavation and construction equipment, as well as ensure that the project adheres to any property line restrictions.

Local building codes and permissions

Before you start digging, it’s essential to familiarize yourself with your local building code requirements and get the necessary permits and permissions. These regulations are in place to ensure the safety and structural integrity of your project. You may need to obtain a permit, submit plans for review, and follow to specific guidelines regarding ceiling height, ventilation, and emergency exits, inspection milestones, etc.

Cost considerations and property value impact

Adding a basement under an existing house can be a significant investment. You’ll need to factor in the costs of excavation, foundation work, and interior finishing. Additionally, consider the potential impact on your property value. While a well-executed basement addition can increase your property’s value, it’s essential to weigh the costs against the potential return on investment before committing to the project.

Preparing for the basement excavation project

With the feasibility evaluation complete, it’s time to prepare for the basement excavation project itself. In this section, we’ll outline the steps you need to take before breaking ground, including consulting professionals, obtaining permits, reviewing relevant policies, and addressing drainage and waterproofing concerns.

Consulting a structural engineer and general contractor

Before starting any excavation work, it’s crucial to consult with a structural engineer and general contractor. These professionals will help you assess the existing structure, design the new basement, and provide guidance on construction methods and materials. They can also assist in obtaining the necessary permits and ensuring your project complies with local building codes.

Checking local laws and obtaining necessary permits

As mentioned earlier, it’s essential to familiarize yourself with local building codes and obtain the necessary permits. Consulting with a general contractor or structural engineer can help streamline this process. It’s crucial to follow all regulations and guidelines to ensure the safety and legality of your project.

Reviewing insurance policies and homeowner’s association rules

Before starting your basement excavation project, review your homeowner’s insurance policy to ensure that you’re covered for any potential damages or issues that may arise during construction. Additionally, check your homeowner’s association rules, if applicable, as some associations may have specific guidelines or restrictions regarding basement additions.

Ensuring proper drainage and waterproofing solutions

Proper drainage and waterproofing are critical components of any basement project, as they help prevent water damage and mold growth. Work with your contractor and engineer to design an effective drainage system and select the appropriate waterproofing materials for your specific soil type and local climate. Adequate planning and execution in these areas will help ensure the long-term success of your basement addition.

Choosing the right basement type and design

Now that you’ve prepared for the excavation process, it’s time to decide on the type and design of your new basement. In this section, we’ll discuss various options for basement styles and finishes, as well as design considerations for optimizing storage, living space, natural light, and ventilation.

Full basement vs. partial basement

A full basement extends under the entire footprint of your house, providing ample space for storage and living areas. On the other hand, a partial basement occupies only a portion of the available space beneath your home, offering a more budget-friendly option. Consider your needs, budget, and the overall impact on your property when deciding between a full or partial basement.

Finished vs. unfinished basement

A finished basement has completed walls, flooring, and ceilings, making it a comfortable and functional living space. An unfinished basement, while less polished, offers a more cost-effective solution and can still be used for storage or utility purposes. Weigh the benefits and costs of each option to determine which best fits your needs and budget.

Design considerations for maximizing storage and living space

When designing your basement, think about how you can maximize both storage and living space. Consider built-in shelving or cabinetry for efficient storage solutions and plan for open, flexible areas that can serve multiple purposes, like a home office, playroom, or guest bedroom. Work with your contractor and engineer to create a layout that meets your specific needs.

Incorporating natural light and ventilation

Natural light and ventilation are important factors in creating a comfortable and healthy basement environment. Consider adding windows, skylights, or light wells to bring in sunlight and fresh air. If natural light is limited, use artificial lighting and mechanical ventilation systems to maintain proper air quality and create a bright, inviting space. Discuss these options with your contractor and engineer to find the best solutions for your basement design.

The basement excavation and construction process

With the right design in place, it’s time to dive into the actual basement excavation and construction process. In this section, we’ll walk you through the key steps involved in transforming your home’s lower level, from preparing the site to installing essential systems.

Preparing the site and supporting the existing structure

Before excavation begins, your contractor will need to prepare the site and ensure your home’s existing structure is adequately supported. This may involve installing temporary shoring or underpinning the foundation to maintain stability during construction. Be sure to consult with your structural engineer to determine the best approach for your specific project.

Digging out the basement and handling dirt removal

Once the site is prepared and the existing structure is secured, the excavation process can begin. Your contractor will dig out the basement area, carefully removing dirt and debris from the site. Keep in mind that dirt removal can be a significant undertaking, so discuss your options for disposal with your contractor.

Constructing the new foundation walls and installing reinforcements

After the basement area has been excavated, it’s time to build the new foundation walls. This typically involves pouring concrete and installing reinforcements like steel beams or wire rebar. Work closely with your structural engineer and contractor to ensure the new foundation walls meet all necessary code requirements and provide adequate support for your home.

Installing plumbing, electrical, and ventilation systems

With the foundation in place, your contractor can now install the necessary plumbing, electrical, and ventilation systems for your new basement. This may include connecting to existing systems or installing entirely new ones, depending on your basement design and local building codes. Collaborate with your contractor and other professionals to ensure all systems are properly installed and meet the required safety standards.

Basement costs and potential return on investment

As we’ve explored the various aspects of adding a basement to an existing home, you might be wondering about the costs involved and the potential return on investment. In this section, we’ll delve into how to estimate the cost of a basement addition and consider whether the investment is worth it for your home.

Estimating the average cost of basement addition

The cost of adding a basement to your home can vary greatly, depending on factors like location, materials, and labor. On average, basement additions can range from $50 to $200 per square foot, but these numbers can fluctuate based on your specific project. It’s crucial to consult with a general contractor to obtain a more accurate estimate for your situation.

Factors affecting the cost: square feet and ceiling height

Many variables can impact the overall cost of your basement addition. Square footage and ceiling height are two primary factors, as larger basements with higher ceilings may require more materials and labor. Other elements to consider include the complexity of the design, the need for additional structural support, and any required upgrades to your home’s existing systems.

Weighing the costs against the value added to the property

When deciding whether to invest in a basement addition, it’s important to weigh the costs against the potential value added to your property. A well-executed basement project can increase your home’s overall value and offer additional living or storage space. However, it’s essential to carefully consider your specific circumstances, like your local housing market and the potential return on investment. Speak with a real estate professional to gain insight into how a basement addition might affect your property’s value.

Common basement-addition challenges

While adding a basement to an existing home offers numerous benefits, it also presents several challenges. So what do you do if you still need space but a basement addition isn’t the right fit for your property?

Dealing with high water tables and limited space

High water tables and limited space are two common challenges when adding a basement to an existing home. In areas with high water tables, proper drainage and waterproofing solutions become even more critical to prevent flooding and water damage.

For instance, here in Florida where I live, even in North Florida, basements are very very rare if ever seen because you only have to dig down just a couple feet virtually anywhere in the state and you will hit water.

If you live in a coastal area, building on stilts or a raised foundation might be a more viable option due to the potential for flooding or unstable soil conditions.

Instead, think about using one of the options below instead of digging out a basement if this is an issue for you.

Adding one of these alternatives can provide additional living space and potentially increase your property’s value.

Determining if a basement addition is the best choice for the existing property

Ultimately, it’s essential to carefully evaluate whether a basement addition is the best choice for your existing property. Consider the challenges you may face, like high water tables, limited space, and local building codes, as well as your budget and goals for the project. Consult with professionals like structural engineers and general contractors to ensure that you’re making an informed decision and that your home can safely accommodate a basement addition.

Exploring alternatives to digging a basement for your existing house

Adding a basement isn’t the only option for increasing living or storage space in your home. In this section, we’ll explore some alternative solutions that you might consider if a basement addition isn’t the right choice for your property.

Converting a crawl space into a basement

One option to think about is converting an existing crawl space into a basement. This can be a lot more cost-effective and less invasive alternative, because requires less excavation and may involve fewer structural changes. However, it’s important to consult with a structural engineer and a general contractor to ensure that your home can safely support this conversion.

Adding a second story

Another possibility is adding a second story to your home. I learned about this idea several years ago from a guest on the Bigger Pockets Podcast who was doing renovations and one way he added a ton of value to existing properties was to “add a level” and so he called them “add-a-levels”.

Just as there are structural engineering challenges with adding a basement, there are also challenges when adding a level. Your home’s foundation has to be able to hold the extra weight, which can really cause problems if you don’t check this box. But a second story can provide additional living space and potentially increase your property’s value. However, make sure to check local building codes and obtain necessary permits before embarking on this project.

Constructing a home addition

A home addition, like a sunroom or a family room, can also provide extra living or storage space without the need for a basement. This can be a more suitable option for properties with limited space or high water tables.

Converting an attic into living space

Another alternative to consider is converting your attic into a functional living space. Depending on the type of roof and the available space, an attic conversion can provide an additional bedroom, office, or recreational area. This option can be more cost-effective than digging a basement and may require fewer structural changes. It’s essential to consult with a structural engineer and a general contractor to determine the feasibility of this project and ensure that your home can support the added weight.

Building detached storage or living spaces

Lastly, if a basement, second story, or home addition isn’t feasible, consider building detached storage or living spaces on your property. This can include structures like garages, sheds, or even a guest house.

Don’t forget to check on local building code requirements and to get the necessary permits before starting any construction work. You don’t want that headache.

Additional Considerations for Basement Construction

As we explore the intricacies of adding a basement to an existing house, it’s important to address some additional factors that could impact your decision-making process. Let’s delve into these unique scenarios and considerations, ensuring you have a comprehensive understanding of what it takes to create the perfect basement space.

Expanding an existing basement

  1. Assessing the current basement’s condition and potential for expansion: It’s essential to evaluate the current basement’s structural integrity, layout, and potential for expansion. Consider hiring an expert to assess your existing basement and provide guidance on the best way to proceed.
  2. Implementing best practices for excavation and construction without compromising the existing structure: Careful planning and execution are crucial when working with an existing basement. Work closely with your contractor to ensure that your basement excavation and construction project doesn’t compromise the existing structure’s stability.

Basement construction in older homes

  1. Unique challenges and considerations for older properties: Older homes may have specific construction challenges, such as outdated building materials, unique architectural elements, or historical preservation restrictions. Be prepared to address these issues as you plan your basement project.
  2. Preserving the architectural integrity and historical value of the home: When adding a basement to an older property, it’s crucial to preserve the home’s architectural integrity and historical value. Consult with a preservation expert or local historical society for guidance on maintaining your home’s unique character.

Balancing the benefits and drawbacks of a major basement project

  1. Weighing the long-term advantages of additional space against the time and cost investment: Adding a basement can significantly enhance your living space, but it also requires a substantial investment of time and money. Carefully consider the benefits of additional space against the required investment before embarking on your project.
  2. Understanding the importance of proper planning and execution for a successful project: A well-planned and executed basement project can add significant value to your home. However, cutting corners or rushing through the process can lead to costly mistakes and even damage your property. Take the time to plan thoroughly and work with experienced professionals to ensure a successful outcome.

Innovative solutions for enhancing your current home

  1. Home lifts as an alternative for connecting main floor spaces with basement areas: If adding a full basement isn’t feasible or desirable, consider installing a home lift to connect the main floor with other levels of your home. This option provides additional accessibility and can increase your home’s value.
  2. Exploring the use of concrete walls and creative ceiling designs for a functional and attractive basement space: When designing your basement, consider using concrete walls for added stability, durability and soundproofing. Additionally, experiment with creative ceiling designs – like finished vs. unfinished, industrial vs. conventional, traditional, etc. – to create a visually appealing and functional space that suits your needs and personal style.

Next Steps

Want to join others who are creating the most amazing home redesigns & renovations and get more tips, tricks and hacks on how to make your home the best it can be?

Join my brand new free private Facebook group, Remodel Reality to connect with other people like you to make your space the best!

Trending Articles

Dive into more home improvement stories below. One of these trending articles might just be the right solution for your problem or inspire your next project's breakthrough.

Posted in

Rob Orr

Me and my family have lived through a nightmare of a remodeling project gone wrong, making countless mistakes including placing trust in the wrong hands. Despite these setbacks, we took matters into our own hands for many aspects of the remodel, ensuring quality workmanship guided by expert advice. Through my personal experiences, I've created RemodelReality.com. My mission is not only to share the pitfalls we encountered but also the successes we achieved by combining our efforts with trusted professionals. By sharing both the highs and lows of our journey, I aim to help others navigate their own remodeling projects with greater confidence, ensuring they benefit from our lessons learned.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *